Blog 2: Using Kant’s Perspective

Deputy Commissioner’s Garden Agra, India, c.1933, by Ethel Carrick

By using moment one of Kant’s Judgment of the beautiful, I hope you will see this art work as beautiful. Originally, I had a different paint by Ethel Carrick Fox but I was unable to find a source.

Art Critique

The above source, linked, is comparing two of Ethel’s painting, one of her earlier works to one of her later works. The article claims that Ethel captures a sense of movement in her work.

Moment 1 of the judgement of taste requires the viewer to look at the work of art aesthetically. I asked my self what kind of pleasure, or displeasure, do I feel? I came to the conclusion that I feel the “feeling of life” as Kant calls it.

With the first step of this moment completed now I look to the second step. Am I disinterested in the subject matter? I absolute loathe being outside, though there are moments where I can appreciate nature’s beauty. Kant writes that in order to satiety this step “we wish only to know if this mere representation of the object is accompanied in me with satisfaction, however indifferent I may be as regards the existence of the object of this representation” (Kant 282). I reached the conclusion that I hold this piece of art with disinterest.

The next step in this moment of judgement is determining if my feeling of satisfaction can not be mistaken for gratification. Kant hold the two in very different regards and only satisfaction is a pure feeling. If my feelings are because of gratification I would not be making a judgment of taste.

Magnified View of top right corner

A critic might claim that the brush strokes are not precise, or clean. This argument would call for the representation to be 100% accurate in order for the representation to pass moment one. However, moment one is about feelings within the observer and if you are eyeing details with such a critical nature than you are not reflecting on your feelings.

Advertisement

2 Comments

  1. alexarushnova says:

    Hello there,

    I really appreciate your post. When I observed this painting and as I read your analysis referencing Kants Moment about disinterest, I walked myself through and can agree with the critique about how this may appear very unrealistic, not clean or precise. Although, as you wrote, “moment one is about feelings within the observer and if you are eyeing details with such a critical nature than you are not reflecting on your feelings.” Therefore, this is 100% true about becoming disinterested in order to truly feel and know that this piece is absolutely beautiful.

    Like

    1. haleykeith1 says:

      Hello,
      Thanks for you comment! I am glad you were able to follow my thought process. Kant was difficult for me to understand, so I’m glad I was able to convey a strong argument with his perspective.

      Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s